I have to admit..you have some pretty sad choices on there. Toyota's are reliable, along with Honda's. If you want incredible gas mileage, you can't beat the Mini. I chose the Mazda because it was the only 'decent' choice. Also, I agree with NOT getting a Mitsubishi...junk.
Make some choices, and then check Consumer Reports for safety and reliability before you buy. If you're going to spend gobs of money, you better be fully informed before some screwball salesman tries to sucker you out of your every last dime.
